Best Marinara Sauce Recipe with Fresh Tomatoes

This homemade marinara sauce is made ultra-simply from scratch with fresh tomatoes, garlic, and herbs. No cans here, just delicious, fresh from the garden tomato sauce! With hundreds of five-star reviews, you can be sure this homemade tomato sauce will be a hit!

If it’s the peak of summer, your garden is churning out more tomatoes than you know what to do with, and you’re hungry…I have two words for you: homemade marinara.

More specifically, a homemade marinara with fresh tomatoes (no canned tomatoes or tomato paste here)! Because summer is all about celebrating that garden-fresh produce, and this marinara is the perfect way to celebrate.

Most recipes will have you blanch the tomato to remove the skin, but I find that it’s unnecessary and takes too much time (plus, the skin has insoluble fiber – double win).

What You Will Love About this Homemade Marinara

After testing this sauce across dozens of batches to land on the right balance of acid and sweetness, here’s why this version is worth making from scratch.

• Made entirely from fresh tomatoes, no cans, no jars, no preservatives, just real produce simmered down into something deeply flavorful.
• Freezes beautifully, so a big batch during tomato season means homemade marinara all year.
• Texture is entirely up to you, leave it rustic and chunky or blend it smooth, both are correct.

@liveeatlearn

This homemade marinara sauce is made ultra-simply from scratch with fresh tomatoes, garlic, and herbs. No cans here, just delicious, fresh from the garden tomato sauce! With almost 300 five-star reviews, you can be sure this homemade tomato sauce will be a hit! 🍅 #tomatoseason #tomatogarden #summerrecipe #tomatorecipes #marinara

♬ SUNFLOWER (Beat) – FreshlyRC

Ingredients for this Marinara Recipe

• Fresh tomatoes: Roma tomatoes are a great choice since they’re meatier with fewer seeds, which means less liquid to cook off. Heirlooms add more complex, sweeter flavor if you have them on hand, but expect a slightly longer simmer time since they hold more water.
• Garlic: Cooked just until fragrant rather than browned, which keeps the flavor mellow instead of sharp or bitter. Burnt garlic will make the whole sauce taste off, so keep the heat at medium and watch it closely.
• Fresh basil: Stir this in toward the end of cooking rather than the beginning. Basil loses its bright flavor quickly with heat, so adding it late keeps the sauce tasting fresh instead of muddled.
• Italian parsley: Look for flat-leaf rather than curly parsley, it has a cleaner, slightly peppery flavor that holds up better in a cooked sauce.
• Honey: The ingredient most people don’t expect in marinara. Just a tablespoon balances the natural acidity of the tomatoes without making the sauce taste sweet, it’s there to round things out, not to be detected.
• Olive oil: A good quality extra virgin olive oil makes a noticeable difference here since the sauce is simple enough that every ingredient’s flavor comes through.
• Salt and pepper: Season gradually and taste as you go, since the concentration of flavor changes a lot as the tomatoes reduce.

How to make marinara sauce

Sauté the garlic in olive oil until fragrant, then add the diced fresh tomatoes and let them simmer uncovered until they break down into a sauce, about 25 minutes. Stir in the fresh herbs, honey, salt, and pepper, then simmer another 10 minutes to let the flavors come together. From there, serve it rustic and chunky, or blend it smooth in a food processor.

Homemade Marinara Top Tips

This homemade marinara sauce recipe is naturally chunky, but you can easily make it into a smooth and silky marinara with a quick blitz in the blender. I prefer to use a handheld immersion blender to puree it right in the pot, but you could also transfer it (carefully – hot!) to a countertop blender.

• Keep it chunky for use with your favorite pasta (like these vegetarian stuffed shells)
• Blend it smooth for use as a dipping sauce (like with air fryer mozzarella sticks!)
• Use ripe, in-season tomatoes. This sauce is only as good as the tomatoes that go into it. Off-season tomatoes tend to be watery and underflavored, which means a longer simmer time and a less vibrant final sauce.
• Don’t skip the honey. It’s a small amount, but it makes a noticeable difference in balancing the acidity of fresh tomatoes. Maple syrup or sugar work as a direct vegan swap.

Marinara recipe variations

This sauce is a great base for using up extra garden produce. A few ideas:

Add diced zucchini or eggplant. Both cook down nicely alongside the tomatoes and add bulk without overpowering the flavor.

Stir in roasted red peppers. Adds sweetness and a slightly smoky depth, especially good if you’re blending the sauce smooth.

Use a mix of tomato varieties. Combining a few different types, like Romas with heirlooms, can add more complexity to the final flavor.

How to use this homemade marinara

This marinara is endlessly useful beyond a simple bowl of spaghetti. Use it as the sauce base for naan pizza, layer it into zucchini lasagna or lazy lasagna casserole, or simmer seitan meatballs directly in it for an easy meatball sub. It’s also the perfect base for cheesy baked rotini pasta casserole when you want something heartier.

How to store homemade marinara

Store leftovers in an airtight container or jar in the fridge for up to 1 week. To freeze, transfer to a freezer-safe container and keep for up to 3 months. When ready to use, thaw overnight in the fridge, then reheat on the stove or in the microwave.

Got fresh tomatoes?

5-Minute Tomato Gazpacho Recipe

5 minutes

10-Minute Summer Veggie Salad

10 minutes

Tomato Basil Soup (With Fresh Tomatoes)

40 minutes

5-Minute Greek Baked Feta

15 minutes